The story is likely a fairy tale. There are at least three other versions—an exact parallel in the Burmese fairy tale “Princess Thudhammasari” and two variants in Cambodian history, one in the eighth and another in the 14th century. Kings of Cambodia claim descent from the gardener.[3]

Various chronicles do not agree on the dates regarding his life and reign.[4] The oldest chronicle Zatadawbon Yazawin is considered to be the most accurate for the Pagan period.[note 1] The table below lists the dates given by four main chronicles, as well as Hmannan’s dates when anchored by the Anawrahta’s inscriptionally verified accession date of 1044.